Rumors have occasionally circulated about the supposed adverse health consequences of eating soy. For a thorough review of these alleged problems, we refer you to the excellent article on soy by John Robbins, which can be accessed at www.foodrevolution.org ("What About Soy?"). To quote from the article: "It is true that the protein in cooked soybeans is slightly less digestible than that found in most animal foods. However, when soybeans are made into soymilk, tofu, tempeh, and the other common forms of soyfoods, their protein digestibility is enhanced and becomes similar to animal foods. Any negative impact on protein digestibility due to the presence of the enzyme inhibitors found in soybeans is rendered nearly irrelevant in such foods. And even simple soybeans, with their reduced digestibility, are so high in protein and in all the essential amino acids that they could still easily serve as the sole source of protein in a person's diet if that was necessary for some reason." One of the main points of Dr. Robbins' article is that most problems associated with soy consumption are when it is consumed in a concentrated state, isolated from whole foods such as tofu and tempeh. Soy isolates, or pure isoflavones, may cause problems when consumed in large quantities. Like any nutritious food, soy is best eaten in moderate quantities and as part of a well-balenced diet, one that is low in saturated fat and high in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and beans. More importantly, soy is best consumed in its natural state, in whole foods like tofu, tempeh, miso, where the full nutritional benefits of soy are readily available. Who should limit soy intake? Most people run little risk in consuming up to 100 mg of soy isoflavones per day. However, studies and experts consulted by Consumer Reports magazine suggested that soy's use by the following groups of people might be problematic:(from July 4 '04 issue of CR; see also www.ConsumerReports.org ) Breast cancer patients. While soy consumption has, according to some studies, appeared beneficial in lowering the chances of contracting breast cancer,(see above) people who already have it should talk with their doctors before taking large amounts of soy. Soy could stimulate any cancer cells present or alter the effectiveness of the breast cancer drug tamoxifen. People on thyroid medication. Research suggests that soy might interfere with body's absorption of thyroid hormone pills. People with a history of kidney stones. Soybeans contain oxalates, a compound associated with increased risk of kidney stones. People allergic to soy. Some 5 to 10% of U.S. babies and toddlers are allergic to soy, as are 1 to 2% of adults. Reactions to soy are rarely severe, however. |